3 churches on record in Shelter Island — from downtown cathedrals to the storefront congregations that shape the city's religious life. 2 distinct traditions, 0 verified entries. It is one of the cities we index across New York, and sits in Suffolk County within the New York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro area. Its largest tradition is Episcopal.
We list 3 churches in Shelter Island, New York, across 2 traditions. Every entry carries the street address and map coordinates, so the nearest congregation to you is the one closest on the map above, not the one that paid for placement. Nobody can pay to appear here. If you are looking for a particular tradition, the largest in Shelter Island is Episcopal with 2 churches; the filters above narrow the list by tradition or by first letter.
For a first visit, the editors recommend three churches: Shelter Island Presbyterian Church (Evangelical), Saint Mary's Episcopal Church (Episcopal), and Saint Marks Episcopal Church (Episcopal). Together they offer a representative sample of Shelter Island's worship life.